Theft, Keys & Security

My car keys were stolen from my house — should I tell my home insurer or car insurer?

Illustration for: My car keys were stolen from my house — should I tell my home insurer or car insurer?
Short answerPotentially both. Home insurance may be relevant to the burglary and stolen household property, while the motor insurer needs to know if the keys could be used to steal the car or compromise its security.

What should you do?

  • Report the theft to the police and keep the crime reference details.
  • Tell your motor insurer promptly and ask about recoding or replacing keys and locks.
  • Notify the home insurer if you are claiming for the burglary or other stolen items.
  • Follow any security instructions given by the motor insurer.

What can make a difference?

The result can depend on your level of cover, exclusions, excess, information given when the policy was arranged or renewed, who was driving, and the precise circumstances. Two policies both described as “comprehensive” can still contain different terms.

The two policies cover different risks, so notifying one insurer does not necessarily notify the other.

The two policies can cover different parts of the incident

Your motor policy may deal with vehicle keys or security, while a home policy may respond to theft from the house. Notify the relevant insurers promptly and let them confirm which costs, if any, fall under each policy.

Looking for car insurance?

Compare quotes from a range of participating insurance providers.

Click here to compare quotes

Powered by Quotezone We are an introducer appointed representative of Seopa Ltd (FCA FRN: 313860). Seopa Ltd, trading as Quotezone, provides the insurance comparison service and we receive a commission for any policies purchased, at no cost to you. We do not offer financial advice.